Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction, September 12, 2026

Final score: Columbus Crew 0-1 New York Red Bulls. Our tip was Columbus Crew or draw (1X) and it lost.

Major League Soccer
Major League Soccer

USA

Sep 12th, 2026
11:30 PM
ScottsMiracle-Gro Field
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
L L W L L
0 : 1
Full Time
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
W L D L D

Why This Tip

49%
24%
27%
Columbus Crew win Draw New York Red Bulls win

PeakyBet's model slightly favours Columbus Crew (49% probability — Columbus Crew 49% / draw 24% / New York Red Bulls 27%). Columbus Crew hold the edge on form, attack and goal model. New York Red Bulls look stronger on defence. PeakyBet tip: Columbus Crew or draw (1X).

60% Form 40%
80% Attack 20%
41% Defence 59%
50% Head-to-head 50%
62% Goal model 38%
Tips: +2.5 1X HWEH x

Model-based analysis from form, attack/defence strength and head-to-head. 18+ · bet responsibly.

Recent form

Columbus Crew – last 5

LWLLL

New York Red Bulls – last 5

LDLDL

Last meetings

Match Odds
Home
1.75
Draw
4.00
Away
3.70
Predictions
Over 2.5
Home Win or Draw
Home Wins Either Half
Draw

Match Info

Status Match Finished
Date Sep 12, 2026
Kick Off 11:30 PM
Venue ScottsMiracle-Gro Field
Head-to-Head & Recent Form
New York Red Bulls
3-2
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
3-1
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
0-0
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
-
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
2-2
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
0-1
New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls
2-3
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
3-0
New York Red Bulls
Columbus Crew
2-1
New York Red Bulls
Columbus Crew - Recent Form
W
FC Cincinnati
0-2
Columbus Crew
W
Columbus Crew
3-1
Charlotte
L
Orlando City SC
3-2
Columbus Crew
W
Columbus Crew
2-1
Inter Miami
W
CF Montreal
0-2
Columbus Crew
L
Orlando City SC
2-1
Columbus Crew
L
Columbus Crew
0-1
New York Red Bulls
L
DC United
2-1
Columbus Crew
W
Columbus Crew
3-0
Colorado Rapids
L
Columbus Crew
1-3
New England Revolution
New York Red Bulls - Recent Form
L
New York Red Bulls
0-2
Toronto FC
L
DC United
2-1
New York Red Bulls
W
New York Red Bulls
4-1
San Diego
L
New York Red Bulls
0-3
St. Louis City
W
New York City FC
0-1
New York Red Bulls
W
Columbus Crew
0-1
New York Red Bulls
L
Los Angeles FC
2-0
New York Red Bulls
D
Seattle Sounders
0-0
New York Red Bulls
L
New York Red Bulls
1-3
Philadelphia Union
D
New York Red Bulls
1-1
Chicago Fire
Columbus Crew
Form
L L W L L
New York Red Bulls
Form
W L D L D

League Table

About Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls

Columbus Crew face New York Red Bulls in Major League Soccer (USA) on Saturday, September 12, 2026 (kick-off 23:30) at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field. On this page you will find PeakyBet's free prediction, betting tips, head-to-head record, recent form and key match facts for Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls.

Recent form: Columbus Crew have recorded 1 win, 0 draws and 4 losses in their last 5 matches, while New York Red Bulls have 1 win, 2 draws and 2 losses in their last 5 matches.

Based on PeakyBet's statistical model, the leading betting angle for Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls points towards: +2.5, 1X, HWEH. Always compare with the latest odds and team news before placing a bet.

The PeakyBet model gives Columbus Crew a 49% chance of winning, the draw 24% and New York Red Bulls 27%. Over 2.5 goals is rated at 52% and both teams to score at 55%.

See all Major League Soccer predictions, today's correct score predictions and the strongest picks of the day.